Hello dear
Welcome to Casella Bagel Coffee Shop
At Casella Bagel Coffee Shop, nestled in downtown Brooklyn, we celebrate the heart of community dining with a twist. This cozy spot blends the essence of a classic diner with a diverse menu that goes far beyond typical bagels and coffee. Whether you're craving a hearty breakfast sandwich or looking to indulge in a mouthwatering gyro platter, our offerings are generous and crafted with care. Customers rave about our attentive service and inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal choice for families, groups, or even a casual date. Experience the comforting flavors and vibrant energy that make Casella a hidden gem in the bustling city.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Two Eggs with Steak
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich
California Wrap
Steak and Onions
About
Casella Bagel Coffee Shop
Welcome to the thriving heart of Brooklyn, where comfort meets flavor at the Casella Bagel Coffee Shop. Located at 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, this cozy eatery is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a delightful escape for food lovers and breakfast enthusiasts alike.
From the moment you step through the door, you’re greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked bagels and brewing coffee. Casella Bagel Coffee Shop deftly blends the charm of a neighborhood diner with the convenience of a modern café. Whether you crave a simple bagel or a hearty sandwich, their extensive menu has something for everyone.
The breakfast offerings are a highlight, showcasing a tempting array of dishes. For just $2.00, you can enjoy a classic bagel, and for a bit more, indulge in a rich bagel with cream cheese for $4.00 or a satisfying bagel with peanut butter for $4.00. Customers rave about options like the bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll for only $4.50, providing a delicious and affordable way to kickstart the day. For those with a sweet tooth, don’t miss the Nutella bagel, which adds a deliciously decadent twist to breakfast.
As you delve deeper into the menu, the hot sandwiches shine brightly. From the highly-rated Philly cheesesteak sandwich priced at $12.00 to the mouthwatering chicken parmigiana offered at $12.50, there’s no shortage of hearty options. The grilled chicken sandwich and the meatball sandwich are also fan favorites, each prepared with care and flavorful ingredients that make every bite a joy.
What makes Casella Bagel Coffee Shop truly special is the vibrant atmosphere and attentive service. Customers have noted the friendly staff, who seem eager to offer recommendations and ensure a pleasant dining experience. The casual yet inviting space is perfect for catching up with friends, enjoying a quick bite, or even a cozy date night.
In a bustling city where food spots often come and go, Casella Bagel Coffee Shop stands out as a beloved gem. It’s a place where value meets quality, and each dish reflects the passion for good food. So, drop by, grab a bagel, and discover why this charming deli has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Don’t just take our word for it; the reviews speak for themselves!
- Location: 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
- Phone: (718) 522-5641
- Breakfast Highlights: Bagels, Muffins, Oatmeal, Grits
- Hot Sandwich Favorites: Philly Cheesesteak, Chicken Parmigiana, Tuna Melt
- Customer Quotes:
- “Great little hole in the wall diner!” - Pam M.
- “The food was good and generously portioned.” - Sarah E.
- “Now my favorite deli in downtown Brooklyn!” - Judah H.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great little hole in the wall diner! Food was good and lots to choose from! Service was fast too. ”
“ The food was good and generously portioned. The service was excellent and fast. Nice seats. ”
“ Colleague from Boston in town..,and we walked into this place! They have everything..,literally everything! Salads, Sandwiches, Rice, Beans, Roasted Chicken...,Beef Patties..., Bagels..,and Cream Cheese..,Muffins..,Cookies..,and more. It's now my favorite deli in downtown Brooklyn!! The Bacon, Egg, Cheese on a roll was only $4.50us. The coffee was pretty good also! Plenty of seating area also..,and this can be a great date spot also. The waitress staff is AWESOME also!! ”
“ Hidden gem! We stopped in based on another Yelp! review stating that it was a full fledged diner, and it was, but without the diner feel. Our waitress was attentive and so friendly. The breakfast menu was massive and everything came pretty quickly. I would recommend it for anyone in the area looking for a delicious breakfast. ”
“ "Bagel Coffee Shop" may be a modest name, but we're talking full fledge diner status. Featuring an easy order-out area, seating availability in the back with waitresses on deck, and more options than the joe shmoe Bagel Shop you're used to.... We're talking an entirely new twist on what a Bagel Coffee Shop can be. ”
“ This place was definitely a surprise--in a good way. I work nearby and my coworkers and I eat lunch out regularly. We normally go to another bagel place but we were looking for a bit of a change to our routine so we gave Casella's a try thinking it would be a basic bagel store. It only has a few bagel options but it has so much more and it has a full sit down area with booths that we were not expecting where a waitress waited on us. They have a full menu ranging from breakfast staples of pancakes, French toast, eggs and waffles to Cuban sandwiches and gyros. I got one of the most expensive items, an avocado omelette with peppers, onions and cheese, and it was only $8.00 or something silly cheap. ”
